Friday, July 04, 2008

Limited Resources

Imagine this meal.

There are 10 people who need to be fed. The restaurant that makes the food only produces enough for 10 people. One of them is obese and eats 45% of the food. The second person is also obese and consumes 45% of the meal. These two really do not eat all the food. They give it to their equally over fed pets. The remaining 8 make do with the last 10% of the food. They have not complained so far at this discrepancy since they did not have any money and were happy at getting even those scraps of food.

Of late 7 of the 8 have become modestly wealthy and proportionately hungrier for more food. The restaurateur unfortunately is unable to cook any more food. But he sees that there is demand for his food and decides to double the price. The 7 are capable and willing to pay more money to get a greater share of the food. This is galling to the two obese people. They are irritated that they have to pay twice the amount they were paying for the same food. To add to their woes, the restaurant owner has also told everyone not to be surprised if food prices will triple in the near future. Now these two can no longer provide gourmet food for their pets.

Horrors!!

Now the two, let it not be forgotten, are still very rich. With money comes the ability to buy air time on TV, Radio, and space in Newspapers. They start circulating stories how these poor people are consuming a lot of the food and are causing ridiculous price rise. They get conservative talk shows to rail against the growing consumerism of those 7. They get the liberal media to write about global warming caused by increasing consumption of those 7. They get SPCA to complain about ill treatment and mal-nutrition of the pets.

In general they avoid talking about the real issue - their obesity, their consumption, their greed.

In case you are dense, or I am too cryptic, or both - here is the cast with real names
  1. Restaurateur - Oil producers
  2. First Obese person - USA
  3. Second Obese person - Europe
  4. Overfed pets - Monstrously big vehicles, centrally heated and cooled McMansions 200 hundred miles from civilization (and more).
  5. 7 poor people - China and India
  6. Last poor person- Others (Africa)
I have never been more irritated by articles in respected newspapers that talk about increasing energy needs in China and India, rising consumption of various commodities and relating it to rising prices and global warming. No one ever mentions even in passing the real number that best describes the quality of life - per capita energy consumption. Well here are some numbers for annual per capita energy consumption in a few countries. See here for a more detailed list.
  1. USA - 7794 (this includes me)
  2. France - 4518
  3. Germany - 4203
  4. UK - 3918
  5. China - 1138
  6. India - 512
  7. Ghana - 400
What do you think?

1 comment:

Jannavi said...

I like your analogy, and the stats that support it. But I don't think anyone is 'blaming' India or China. True, up until recently, it was just the bigwigs, US and Europe. The world is 'noticing' only now that there is a growing middle class in these two countries, and that they can afford more and they should be considered level playing field. So this has made food consumption a crisis.

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/03/29/business/worldbusiness/29rice.html?pagewanted=1&_r=1&sq=india%20china%20rice%20consumption&st=cse&scp=1

OK Prez GWB did say, India and China are consuming more rice, and ok he may not have said it well (like many other gaffes of his) but in US's defense, he wasn't saying anything wrong. It was the Indians who got all so 'hurt' by his statement. I have been meaning to blog about this myself. We all know the Indian middle class has gotten very rich and unfortunately for India, some of their habits emulating the West is not for their best. Like everything else, you live and learn, I guess!
The article below is one of many that speaks for this new Indian lifestyle.
http://www.nytimes.com/2006/09/13/world/asia/13diabetes.html?scp=1&sq=india%20middle%20class%20obesity%20heart%20disease&st=cse

You must accept there is the element of global warming adding to this potboiler. How about the fact that Australian farmers are switching to growing grapes for wine in their rice fields, due to arid conditions? I am sure if this were said about India, the junta would sulk and say 'OMG, look, now the world is saying we are becoming drunkards!' :-)

PS: I don't know if the links made it ok on my comments.